Skip to content

Delicious Pies, Fresh from Classic Bakery

At Classic Bakery, our pies are baked with love, care, and only the finest ingredients. Each one is crafted to bring a little joy to your table:

πŸ“ Strawberry Pie – Bursting with fresh, ripe strawberries layered over a flaky crust, this pie is sweet, simple, and always a favorite.

πŸ‹ Lemon Meringue Pie – Smooth lemon filling topped with golden, fluffy meringue creates a perfect balance of tart and sweet.

πŸ’š Key Lime Pie – Creamy and tangy with just the right touch of sweetness, nestled in a buttery crust.

πŸ₯§ Pecan Pie – Rich, nutty, and indulgent, this classic pie brings comfort in every slice.

πŸ‘ Peach Chiffon Cake – Light, airy, and packed with fresh peach flavor, this pie is a refreshing twist that’s as beautiful as it is delicious.

Availability may vary, so be sure to call the bakery for pricing and to confirm your favorite is in store. From fruity and refreshing to rich and decadent, Classic Bakery has a pie for every craving. Please order ahead 24 hours in advance!

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday- Β Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.

Β 

Latest Posts

Freshly Printed & Fully Customizable Cookies at Classic Bakery!

We’re bringing creativity to a whole new level with our direct-to-food printer! From cute and spooky Halloween characters

Game Day Just Got Sweeter with Team Spirit Cookies!

Cheer on your favorite team in the sweetest way possible β€” with printed cookies from Classic Bakery! Thanks

Celebrate Labor Day with Classic Bakery Treats

Celebrate Labor Day with festive red, white, and blue baked goods from Classic Bakery! ✨ Our Flag Cake