Thanksgiving Ordering & Holiday Hours at Classic Bakery

The holiday season is almost here, and we want to make sure you don’t miss out on your favorite treats from Classic Bakery! Please take note of our important Thanksgiving ordering and pickup dates below.

📦 Shipping Orders

The last day to order Kolache for shipping is November 16, 2025.
All shipped orders will go out on November 19, 2025.

🏠 In-Store Pickup Orders

The last day to place pickup orders before Thanksgiving is November 23, 2025.
Please note — orders cannot be picked up prior to 8:00 AM.

🕓 Holiday Hours

  • Tuesday, November 25: Open 6:30 AM – 6:00 PM

  • Wednesday, November 26 (Day Before Thanksgiving): Open 6:30 AM – 4:00 PM

  • Thanksgiving Day: Closed

  • Friday, November 28: Resume normal business hours

📍 Classic Bakery – 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514
📞 330-726-1729

And great news — our famous Pecan Pies are back! 🥧 Perfect for your Thanksgiving table, they’re made fresh and filled with that rich, nutty flavor everyone loves.

Be sure to get your orders in early — holiday favorites go fast!

Call the bakery for prices, availability, or to place your custom order today.

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday-  Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.

Freshly Printed & Fully Customizable Cookies at Classic Bakery!

We’re bringing creativity to a whole new level with our direct-to-food printer! From cute and spooky Halloween characters to cozy fall designs, our printed cookies are a sweet way to celebrate the season. Each cookie is baked fresh and topped with detailed, edible images that look just as good as they taste.

You’ll find two new collections in the shop — fun Halloween cookies featuring pumpkins, ghosts, and friendly monsters, and our fall-themed cookies with cozy designs like acorns, autumn leaves, and “feelin’ pumpkin spicy” messages.

But that’s not all — we’re also printing Boardman Spartan cookies for game days and school spirit events! 🏈 Show off your pride with a custom cookie that sports your team’s logo.

✨ Whether it’s your school mascot, business logo, or any personal design — we can print it right on a cookie!

 

📞 Call the bakery for prices, availability, or to place your custom order today.

 

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday-  Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

 

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.

Game Day Just Got Sweeter with Team Spirit Cookies!

Cheer on your favorite team in the sweetest way possible — with printed cookies from Classic Bakery! Thanks to our new direct-to-food printer, we can bring detailed designs right onto our fresh-baked cookies.

For today’s game, we’re featuring cookies with the Ohio State Buckeyes and YSU Penguins logos — perfect for tailgates, watch parties, or sharing with friends and family. Not only do they look amazing, but they taste just as good as they look. 🍪✨

And the best part? We can print virtually any design — from sports teams and school logos to personal celebrations. The possibilities are endless!

📞 Call the bakery for prices, availability, or to place your custom order today.

Bring a tray of these cookies to your next game day gathering, and you’ll be the MVP of the party!

 

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday-  Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.

Celebrate Labor Day with Classic Bakery Treats

Celebrate Labor Day with festive red, white, and blue baked goods from Classic Bakery!

✨ Our Flag Cake is a holiday favorite — three layers of white cake with fresh blueberries and strawberries, iced in real whipped cream, and decorated in a patriotic finish.

🍪 We’re also baking iced flag and star sugar cookies, hand-decorated daily, plus patriotic cupcake cakes and personalized cakes to make your gathering extra special.

With our recently added direct-to-food printer, we can now create flag cookies with incredible detail — and even print virtually any design to make your treats one-of-a-kind.

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday-  Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.

Delicious Pies, Fresh from Classic Bakery

At Classic Bakery, our pies are baked with love, care, and only the finest ingredients. Each one is crafted to bring a little joy to your table:

🍓 Strawberry Pie – Bursting with fresh, ripe strawberries layered over a flaky crust, this pie is sweet, simple, and always a favorite.

🍋 Lemon Meringue Pie – Smooth lemon filling topped with golden, fluffy meringue creates a perfect balance of tart and sweet.

💚 Key Lime Pie – Creamy and tangy with just the right touch of sweetness, nestled in a buttery crust.

🥧 Pecan Pie – Rich, nutty, and indulgent, this classic pie brings comfort in every slice.

🍑 Peach Chiffon Cake – Light, airy, and packed with fresh peach flavor, this pie is a refreshing twist that’s as beautiful as it is delicious.

Availability may vary, so be sure to call the bakery for pricing and to confirm your favorite is in store. From fruity and refreshing to rich and decadent, Classic Bakery has a pie for every craving. Please order ahead 24 hours in advance!

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday-  Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.

 

Printed to Perfection: Baby Elephant Cake Magic

Our edible printer brought this charming baby elephant cake to life — a picture-perfect centerpiece for any baby shower or little one’s birthday! At Classic Bakery, we turn your sweetest ideas into custom edible designs. From adorable animals to themed celebrations, we’re here to make your cake dreams a reality.

Have a design in mind? Call the bakery for pricing and to discuss your custom request — we’re happy to help bring your vision to life!

Personalized cakes are made to order. Limited availability within the store. Please order ahead 24 hours in advance!

 

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday-  Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.

 

Celebrate the 4th of July with Classic Bakery!

Get ready for the 4th of July with red, white, and blue baked goods from Classic Bakery!

Try our delicious Flag Cake: three layers of white cake stacked on top of blueberries and fresh-cut strawberries. Iced in real whipped cream and finished in a patriotic display of whipped cream, strawberries, and blueberries.

We also have a variety of other stars and striped-themed items such as our iced flag and star sugar cookies, each individually hand-decorated daily in our store. Or go all-out with personalized patriotic cakes or flag-inspired cupcake cakes.

Personalized cakes are made to order. Limited availability within the store. Please order ahead 24 hours in advance!

HOLIDAY HOURS: Friday, July 4th, Open at 6:30 AM & closing at 2:00 PM

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday-  Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.

 

Key Lime Time! Our Seasonal Favorite Is Back

Our seasonal Key Lime Pie is back!
Made with a tangy lime filling and a buttery graham cracker crust, it’s the perfect balance of sweet and tart. Available for a limited time—stop in and enjoy a slice of summer!

Stop in today or call us to place an order!

 

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday-  Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.

Father’s Day with Classic Bakery

Celebrate Father’s Day with Classic Bakery this year! Choose from a selection of handmade, decorated cakes crafted in-store daily.

Stop in today or call us to place an order!

 

Regular Business Hours:

Wednesday-  Saturday: 6:30 am-6:00 pm

Sunday: 6:30 am-5:00 pm

Closed: Monday & Tuesday

Located at: 7135 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown, OH 44514.

Phone Number: 330-726-1729

  • Classic Bakery’s Return Policy requires the item to be fully intact when returned to the store.
  • All orders are now required to be prepaid 48 hours in advance. Payments can be made over the phone or in-store. The minimum cancellation time for orders is 24 hours, no refunds will be given for same-day cancellations.